NFCCA

Stories from the NFCCA Newsletter, the “Northwood News”

Northwood News ♦ April 2008

Price Comparisons Among Six Local Grocery Stores

By Jacquie Bokow

Since we have so many choices now, I thought it would be interesting to compare prices among the various grocery stores in our area.  I was surprised at how difficult it was!  I absolutely could not find comparable paper products (paper towels, toilet paper, or facial tissues), so I left them off the list.  The amounts are all everyday prices recorded March 12-20.

I discovered Woodmoor Market basically sells beer and wine, with a few fruits and veggies thrown in.  If you need chips and beer for a party quick, it’s the place to go, but there isn’st much else.

Trader Joe’s, a “gourmet” cooperative, mostly carries its own brands, and nearly everything at better prices.  For instance, it sells Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream only in quarts, but the price is $3.99, the same price — or cheaper — as a pint elsewhere ($4.19 at Safeway)!

The biggest surprise was Magruder’s, which I had been told was expensive.  It certainly had the best selection of many items — including milks, Pop-Tarts, pickles, honey, and Ramen Noodles.  Both Magruder’s and Shopper’s had large selections of Progresso Soups and Kosher items not seen elsewhere.

Magruder’s also had a large selection of pastas, but SuperFresh was tops for whole wheat pastas.

And it had always seemed to me that Safeway was more expensive than other stores; now I have proof.

[If you’d like to see other comparisons, call the editor.]   ■

ItemGiantSafewayMagruder’sShopper’sTrader Joe’sSuper Fresh
1 doz. Large Eggs$2.39$3.29$2.19$2.29$1.79$2.09
1/2 gal. Tropicana O.J.$3.49$4.69$4.39$3.28$2.99*$3.49
PF 100% Wh. Wh. Bread$3.69$3.69$3.69$3.49N.A.$3.69
1/2 gal. 1% Milk$2.39$2.59$2.27$2.25$1.99$2.29
16-oz. 4% Cottage Cheese$2.00$2.89$2.49$2.62$2.29$2.29
8-oz. Sour Cream99¢$1.49$1.09$1.29$1.69†$1.09
$/lb Chicken (boneless, skinless breast)$3.99$5.49$2.49$3.49$3.49$5.29
$/lb Beef (80% lean)$2.49$3.99$1.99$3.29$2.49$2.99
$/lb Salmon Fillets$7.99$7.99$7.99$7.99$7.99$7.99
$/lb Granny Smith Apples$1.49$1.69$1.28$1.5049¢ ea.$1.99
5-lb Bag Idaho Potatoes$2.99$3.29$2.50$2.98$2.99$3.99
1 Cucumber75¢79¢34¢$1.00$2.29**67¢
$/lb Bananas54¢54¢49¢53¢49-53¢‡69¢
$/lb Green Peppers$1.89$1.99$2.48$1.00 ea.$1.99††$2.49
1-lb Baby Carrots$1.50$1.99$1.50$1.98$1.69^$1.99
42-oz. Quick Oats$2.79$3.59$2.99$2.39N.A.$3.29
64-oz. Edy’s Ice Cream$4.49$6.49$5.99$3.79N.A.$5.79
10.75-oz. Campbell’s Chicken Noodle Soup$1.00$1.0099¢85¢N.A.85¢
16-oz. Bag Lentils75¢85¢99¢62¢N.A.59¢

*Trader Joe Brand Only • **Hydroponic Only • †Only 16 oz. Available • ‡19¢ Each • ††But Two in a Package • ^Organic Only


   © 2008 NFCCA  [Source: https://nfcca.org/news/nn200804d.html]